Down 28 lb in 16 weeks, but the scale hasn't moved in 23 days. Waist is down 4 inches, shirts fit differently, and my fasting glucose went 102 to 91, triglycerides 180 to 120, HDL up 8. I lift 3x/week, walk 8k steps, eat ~1800 cal and 120g protein.
Is this a classic recomposition plateau, or am I just retaining water from a training bump? Curious whether others saw measurements change while weight sat still for weeks. What finally moved the number for you?
Your glucose and triglyceride drop is the real win. I stalled around week 14 too, same 3 weeks, then lost 2 lb overnight after a higher-carb dinner. Water shifts are weird.
I'd trust the tape less if you're pulling it tighter than before. Are you measuring at the same spot and time? My waist loss was partly better posture.
Same spot, morning, after bathroom. But yeah, I had a two-week stretch where bloating from lifting made the tape look worse, then it caught up.
What's your weekly average weight? Daily numbers are noise. I only count Monday morning averages and my 3-week stall was flat on that too.
Stalls can just be creatine, honestly. Anyone adding it for lifting can pick up like 3 lb of water in 10 days, panic, drop it, whoosh. Not saying that's you.
Creatine doesn't cause 3 lb for everyone though. I've taken it for a year and my weight trend didn't change. Could be cortisol/sleep for you.
Sleep is my hidden lever. Under 6 hours for a week and my scale freezes, appetite jumps, waist stays same. When I fix sleep, the drop shows up in 4-5 days.
The 28 lb in 16 weeks is fast. Maybe your body is just taking a breather. I did a 2-week maintenance break at 1700 cals and lost 1.5 lb during it.
Did your lifting volume go up recently? I added squats 2x/week and my scale stalled 4 weeks while my thighs got bigger. Measurements confused me until I checked progress photos.
I've been where you are. Lost 24 lb over 18 weeks, then sat at 181-183 for almost a month. Waist went from 38 to 35.5, fasting glucose 99 to 88, triglycerides 165 to 110.
What broke it for me wasn't cutting more; it was keeping protein high, walking after dinner, and actually sleeping. The scale finally moved after a stressful work project ended, 2.4 lb down in three days.
The whoosh wasn't magic, just watre finally letting go. You're not stalled, you're remodeling.
What does your weekly average look like?
I stalled 26 days around week 14 and my waist kept shrinking; the scale finally dropped 2.8 lb after a lighter week, so I stopped weighing daily and now just track a 7-day average plus waist at navel. At 1800 cal and 120g protein with 3 lifts, I'd bet water/glycogen is masking fat loss.
Are your calories consistent on weekends, or is Sunday brunch sneaking in?
My scale sat at 186 for 24 days while my belt went in two notches; I was sleeping 5.5 hours and stressed, then took a deload and slept 7.5 for a week and woke up 3 lb lighter. The tape is telling the truth. What's your sleep and stress looking like right now?
Waist down 4 inches is the real scoreboard. The scale is just lagging gossip.
I'd frame those labs and hide the scale for a month. Tape measure wins.
Friday through Sunday was my hidden plateau — I'd eat clean Mon-Thu then clock 500-700 extra on weekend takeout and a couple drinks, which is basically a 0.3 lb/day average. Weight sat flat for 19 days while my jeans got loose in the thighs.
The tell was my Monday morning weight was always 2-3 lb up, then gone by Thursday. Worth logging a couple of full weekends before blaming the gym.
Honestly I'd bet on sleep before the training bump. I hit a 26-day flat stretch where I was sure lifting was holding water, but my resting HR was up 6 bpm and I was averaging 5.5 hours for like ten days because of work. Weighed same, waist same, mood trash.
When I got back to 7-7.5 hours for a week, I dropped 2.8 lb in six days without changing food or lifting. The water from a new program usually clears in 7-14 days; three weeks flat with a shrinking waist sounds more like cortisol and sleep debt masking fat loss.
What's your average sleep been the last three weeks, and is your resting HR or HRV telling you anything? That'd narrow it down more than any scale trick.
Sizes don't lie. I bought a medium 'goal' shirt in February and wore it by April while the scale moved 4 lb.
The one I always catch: eyeballing portions. I swore I was at 1800 but weighed everything for five straight days and landed at 2160 — olive oil when cooking, a scoop of peanut butter I never logged, coffee creamer.
Not saying you're wrong, but 120g protein plus lifting at 1800 can mean the margin is thinner than it looks, and a 300-calorie miss is basically maintenance. Then the scale stalls and we blame water.
Try breaking down a normal day on a food scale, weekends included, and compare. Have you weighed a typical full week, not just the good days?
Four inches off the waist in 23 days is not a stall, that's a win. The tape measure doesn't care what the scale says.
Login to reply to this thread.
Login / Sign up