38M, 5 ft 9, SW 232, CW 212. I've been eating 1850-2000 cal for 16 weeks and losing steadily until five weeks ago. Scale hasn't moved since: 212.0, 212.4, 211.8, 212.2, 212.1.
But waist is down another 2 inches, lifting 3x/week is still progressing, and my fasting glucose went 102 to 96 and A1c 5.7 to 5.5. I weigh food, 8k steps. Is this a real plateau or is body recomp masking fat loss? Should I cut calories, add steps, or wait it out?
Waist down 2 inches? I'd trust the tape over the scale.
Tape over scale is right. Same for me around 20 lbs down: lifting stalled the scale for a month, then it whooshed.
Could also be water. Any higher-carb or salty meals lately? It can hide fat loss for a week or two.
Five weeks is annoying, not forever. Are your lifts still climbing?
If lifts are up and waist is down, that looks like recomp. Maybe add steps before cutting more.
The calculator TDEE thing gets me too. Mine says 2500, but tracking 1900 for six weeks lost only 1.5 lbs. My real maintenance was closer to 2200. NEAT drops hard in a deficit. I added a 20-min walk after dinner and broke a stall without touching food.
I weigh weekly, same day, after bathroom, before food. Weekly averages saved my sanity.
How is your protein? I bumped to 140g and the 4pm hunger got way better.
Your A1c and fasting glucose improved. That is real progress the scale cannot show.
I would disgaree on adding cardio immediately. Fixing 6.5 sleep might matter more than that extra walk.
I would take a two-week maintenance break. Not a free-for-all, just add 200-300 cal mostly carbs around training.
Every time I have done that after a long deficit, the scale jumps 2 lbs from water then settles lower by week three. It also gave me sanity. But if you are not miserable, you can also just hold course and compare monthly averages.
Can you pos tweekly average weights? A 2-inch waist drop with a stall sounds like water and muscle.
Five weeks of identical scale numbers but two inches off your waist and better glucose/A1c is not a plateau in fat loss — that’s a measurement problem, not a progress problem. The scale is a dumb sum of fat, muscle, glycogen, food volume, and water, and lifting 3x/week can absolutely add intramuscular water and glycogen fast enough to hide 2-3 lbs of fat loss.
I’d stop judging by weekly numbers and switch to a 10-day rolling average plus waist at the same spot: navel, relaxed exhale, morning, before food. Did anything change around week 12 — creatine, new rep scheme, more carbs, worse sleep, extra sodium? Any of those can add a few pounds of water while your waist shrinks.
If your lifts are still progressing and waist is down, I’d hold calories another 3-4 weeks before changing anything. The one thing I’d check is whether your weight trend is truly flat on the rolling average or just bouncing inside a 2-lb range.
Take the waist thing seriously, but make sure it’s not measurement error. I was convinced I lost two inches until I realized I was measuring after work vs. first thing.
Now I do navel at the same time, exhale normal, no sucking in, and mark the tape spot. If it’s still down consistently, you’re recomping. I’d trust that over a five-week scale flatline.
Sleep is the sneaky one for me. If I drop under 6.5 hours for a week, my scale jumps 2-3 lbs and sits there, even when calories and steps are identical. Stress does the same. Did sleep, work stress, or training volume change around week 12? If yes, I’d fix that before cutting calories further.
Check your weekly intake, not just daily. I stalled at 20 lbs for six weeks and swore I was at 1900, but when I added up Friday through Sunday it was cloer to 2600 average — oils, bites, a couple IPAs, whatever. Daily logging looked fine; the week didn’t.
The weird part was my waist still dropped because I’d added lifting and my scale was holding water. So I didn’t cut calories, I just tightened weekends for three weeks and the scale finally moved.
What do your Friday-Sunday numbers actually look like, not the weekday ones? If weekends are clean and sleep and steps are stable, then yeah, I’d call it recomp and hold steady.
Also, 16 weeks at 1850-2000 is a long stretch — a 1-2 week maintenance break can sometimes help adherence more than another deficit push.
Pants don't lie — I'm down two belt notches during a six-week scale freeze. Take the win.
I stalled for six straight weeks at 196 — 196.2, 196.0, 195.8, 196.4, you get the idea — after losing 34 lbs, and what broke it was eating at maintenance for ten days, not cutting harder. I'd been sitting at 1750-1850 for months, lifts were grinding, I was cold all the time and ravenous by 8pm.
Against every instinct I went up to about 2600 for ten days, mostly adding carbs and an extra meal. Scale jumped 4 lbs of water on day two and I nearly quit, then it fell off and I dropped 3.5 lbs over the next week and a half, and my bench went up 15 lbs.
The tell for me was that hunger was climbing and gym numbers had flattened. Yours are still progressing, which is why I'd probably hold steady another 3-4 weeks before changing anything — the scale is usually the last thing to move, not the first.
Worth a look: 20 lbs down drops your maintenance maybe 100-150 cal, and 8k steps burns less at 212 than it did at 232. I had to add about 1500 steps just to keep the same deficit. Also, are your lifts going up in weight, or just reps at the same load?
Reps still count as progression, but it's a smaller stimulus change than adding plates.
Login to reply to this thread.
Login / Sign up